I have a very crappy memory about some of the strange mental exercises Kristy and I collaborate on. Thankfully, Kristy is more inclined to recall our more creative moments (and save documents) than I am, so she was able to dredge up our attempt to a dream cast for the musical Into the Woods. We had a few minor holes to plug in tonight, but we managed to figure out those final few (the Steward, for example) to bring you the cast that we’d assemble if we could. This list involved a lot of thought–weighing Willie Nelson against members of ZZ Top, evaluating what artist would be most likely to be the embodiment of a tree, splitting roles to accommodate just the right people. And here we have it:
Narrator–Dule Hill
Cinderella — Andrea Corr
Baker – Neil Patrick Harris
Baker’s Wife–Zooey Deschanel
Jack–Eric Millegan
Jack’s Mother–Mary McDonnell
Little Red Ridinghood–Amber Riley*
Cinderella’s Stepmother–Allison Janey
Florinda–Tricia Helfer
Lucinda–Kristen Bell
Cinderella’s Father — Nathan Fillion
Cinderella’s Mother — Emmylou Harris
Mysterious Man –Willie Nelson
Wolf–Antonio Banderas
Rapunzel–Kristen Chenowith
Rapunzel’s Prince–James Roday
Grandmother–Reba**
Cinderella’s Prince–Hugh Jackman
Steward — TJ Thyne
Giant’s Wife — Patricia Belcher***
Snow White — Michaela Conklin
Sleeping Beauty — Maggie Lawson
Baker’s Baby — Ardilla Voladora****
